"Grim milestone," yes, but hold the politics

Recently the media noted that according to a survey, a relatively small number of Americans knew that the death toll among U.S. servicemembers in Iraq was, at that point, approaching 4,000. As we all know, that number was reached this week. It was, in words appearing in 1,821 separate journalistic entries found on Google News, a "grim milestone."

In a single New York Times article it was not only called a grim milestone, but a "dire water mark," a "sober moment," a "somber development," "heartbreaking news," and a "grim new toll." It was all those things, of course, but one wonders if the very repetition tends toward numbness.

Worse is the way the news has been politicized, as such news frequently is. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, Democrats, threw the news into the White House's face. Pelosi said Americans do not want "continuation of the President's plan for a 10-year, three trillion dollar war in Iraq."

Conservative bloggers, in turn, castigated war critics and "blatantly anti-war wire services [that are] salivating and drooling" over the milestone. (Littlegreenfootballs.com).

Amid the verbal fisticuffs, the advice of one veterans advocate made sense. Paul Rieckhoff, executive director of Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America, who himself has been a critic of the war, said in a statement: "The 4,000th killed-in-action in Iraq is newsworthy, but the truth is that every death should be a news item. The 4,000th death should not be expoited in the polarized arguments about the war. Honoring the fallen is neither a pro- nor an anti-war statement. It's about respecting the sacrifice of thousands of America's sons and daughters."

Hopefully, Most "Grim Milestone" Commentators Are Sincere

Good point, Dave. There has been a lot of coverage of the 4,000th war death and the 4,000 war deaths. Although, I would hasten to add, and hope, that the vast majority of those who have commented on the recent “grim milestone” are not politicizing the occasion, but are sincerely saddened by the continued loss of life in Iraq. I have myself written several Letters commemorating, mourning and honoring those who are represented by this latest “grim milestone.” And, talking about the New York Times coverage, the four full pages of photos of the 1,002 American service members that have been identified as killed since Jan. 1, 2007, published by the Times today, left a lasting impression with me. I am sure that the Times devoted this much effort and copy to “ [respect] the sacrifice of... America’s sons and daughters,” as veterans advocate Paul Rieckhoff would want it.

Maj. Dorian de Wind (Ret.)

Advertisement

See who's been Spotted!

American Gladiators @ Suwon Gym Lakenheath Treasure Trove Daegu Cheerleaders 2009

Check out the latest additions to our community photo site!

About the Author

Dave Mazzarella served as Stars and Stripes ombudsman from 2000 to 2001 before becoming the paper's editorial director. He returned to the ombudsman's chair in February 2007 and served in the role until his retirement in January 2009. He was succeeded by current ombudsman Mark Prendergast.

Recent Comments for Readers' Corner